Sherman "Tiger" Joyce, president of the American Tort Reform Association (ATRA), expressed concerns about a new report that analyzes California trial attorneys' campaign contributions. The report suggests these contributions may have potential influence on legislative and judicial decisions. Joyce voiced his concerns in a press release dated March 19.
"These reports unveil a troubling reality wherein trial lawyers wield significant influence over our legal and political institutions," said "Tiger" Joyce. "The significant campaign contributions from plaintiffs' firms raise concerns about the potential influence on legislative and judicial decisions. Meanwhile, trial lawyers run aggressive ad campaigns, often utilizing dubious claims, to solicit clients."
According to the ATRA's press release, the report revealed that between 2017 and 2023, twenty plaintiffs’ firms contributed more than $15.473 million to California political campaigns and committees. The Law Offices of Walkup, Melodia, Kelly & Schoenberger emerged as the top contributor with donations exceeding $2.5 million. Four other firms - Cotchett, Pitre & McCarthy; Knight Law Group; Singleton Schreiber; and Altair Law - each contributed over $1 million.
The press release further stated that more than 43%, or $6.7 million, of the political donations from these top twenty contributors were directed towards committees affiliated with the Consumer Attorneys of California, described as "the state’s leading advocacy group for trial lawyers." Nearly $2 million of these firms’ contributions were given to Gov. Gavin Newsom.
In their statement, ATRA pointed out that "excessive tort costs" are impacting individual Californians who are burdened with an additional "tax" of almost $2,300 annually due to litigation costs. Joyce said: "As Californians grapple with the implications of excessive tort costs and the pervasive influence of trial lawyers, it’s critical to seek fair and just legal reforms," adding that "A solid future for California’s civil justice system demands a commitment to transparency, accountability, and the pursuit of justice for all."
ATRA is described on its website as a nationwide network of state-based legal reform groups. Established by the American Council of Engineering Companies in 1986 and soon joined by the American Medical Association, ATRA operates at both state and federal levels to ensure fairness in the civil justice system.